Ok so it’s literally the middle of the night but I can’t sleep bc I feel like I broke the code or something (English is not my first language sorry for any mistakes plus im very tired so actually sorry for everything)
!spoilers ahead!
Ok, so… I don’t think Rose Quartz was the part of the The Great Diamond Authority BUT LISTEN UP first of all, she’s too small, second of all her gem isn’t a diamond and it’s placed on her stomach. Why the placement is so important? Well…
Both blue and yellow diamond have their gems on their chest, right?
And White Diamond’s gem is on her forehead.
There are two diamonds with a gem on their chest. And two diamonds (white and pink) with a gem on their forehead. It fits. Also there’s this:
Blue Diamond’s Pearl’s gem is on her chest. Blue Diamond’s gem is on her chest.
So if our Pearl’s gem is on her forehead it means Pink Diamond’s gem was also on her forehead.
And dont forget what Peridot said:
“Well, you’re a quartz. They’re huge, loyal soldiers”
So what I’m saying is Rose was Pink Diamond’s bodyguard but she killed the bitch and started a rebellion with Pink Diamond’s Pearl. This is also the reason why nobody is talking about Pink Diamond – it’s simply because she failed.
That is all, I can finally sleep in peace, goodnight
I LIKE THIS it also explains why all the gems ONLY call each other by gem name, nothing else, ever, and they call rose quartz, rose quartz. it seems like if she was a pink diamond they’d still be calling her that, the renegade diamond, or something.
The ‘Rose killed Pink Diamond’ theory is fantastic and is also strengthened by the mural we saw in a previous episode;
Rose is wielding a Pink Diamond in the mural and she’s surrounded by droids and what looks like Kindergarten drills/droids. Which leads me to-
We could theorize Pink Diamond was in charge of the experiment/technology development division of Earth- or at least in charge of overseeing Kindergartens, since the ship had landed on Earth so long ago and was absolutely covered in Gem-powered weaponry (and we know from Lapis they are actual imprisoned Gems). Rose, seeing humanity and growing to care for them, would strike out at the one who would be in position to deal the most harm to Earth and we know from previous episodes Kindergartens kill the planet from the inside.
Add in Garnet claiming Rose ‘Must have known’ about the fusion monsters, which insinuate Rose dealt with the Kingergartens (because I’m still fairly iffy the experiments were Homeworlds response to Sapphire’s and Ruby’s fusion since those things were there before all that and after the rebellion it was only Peridot who woke them up- and the clusters being there before would make even more sense as to why they were all disgusted by Garnet since cross-gem fusions were seen as literal abominations) But either way that comment claims Rose dealt with science and gem tech (and we know her personal room and weaponry use fairly high end tech) so Rose being subordinate to a gem who deals extensively with gem technology like an overseer for Kindergartens would explain Rose’s knowlege of all that.
It would also explain why Homeworld viewed the rebellion as so dangerous- since both Rose and Pearl defied their established castes aka Quartz being unfailingly loyal and Pearls being decorations, and Rose killed one of the leaders and won the ensuing war despite being a ‘lesser’ gem. That would make Rose’s story 100x better in my opinion- that she wasn’t already a ‘leader’ gem who just had a change of heart, but rather a subordinate gem who saw all the injustice her race were doing and couldn’t stand for it anymore and successfully killed Pink Diamond and defended the Earth. It could also be why Rose’s symbol had a triangle in the middle-
Not to show she is a Diamond but rather she killed one of the most powerful gems on Homeworld. Like a trophy or a warning not to mess with her, despite her playful demeanor.
Rose Quartz being an actual Quartz and not a Diamond who said ‘fuck you’ to the dictatorial Homework, caste system and their terrible leaders and kicked their asses 2k16
reckless & terribly gay 